I just found another original character that has been elusive ie. 趖
The modern meaning is to 'walk fast' but the 'sitting down' character 坐 indicate to the contrary that the original meaning is 'to walk like sitting' ie. walk very slowly.
趖來趖去 was a favorite expression I often hear.
Benzi/Original character
Re: Benzi/Original character
Does anybody know the original character for encounter 'Tu'. It doesn't seem to be 遇 because consonant and tone don't match.
Re: Benzi/Original character
林寶卿 suggests 拄. Initially, I thought 睹 was a likely candidate.
Re: Benzi/Original character
Thanks mark,Mark Yong wrote:林寶卿 suggests 拄. Initially, I thought 睹 was a likely candidate.
拄 is also confirmed in the UCLA website.
The sound and tone is correct but the modern meaning of 拄 is actually to 'poke' which is also a min word. So I am not sure whether this is the right character.
Last edited by xng on Sun Sep 06, 2009 2:08 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Benzi/Original character
Mark yong,Mark Yong wrote:xng,
這一 - Cit (combination of Cia and It) / This
This is quite unlikely, as 這 for "this" is a late 假借 borrowing in Mandarin from a character that originally meant "to go towards".
You're right, 之 should be the original character, 《诗经》:“之子于归”(这小孩出嫁)
The ucla website is wrong on 這.
Found 3 more elusive original characters that is different from mandarin/cantonese from
http://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/闽南语
忝Tiam2:疲《诗经·小宛篇》:“无忝尔所生”(不要累了你的父母)
(This is questionable because the meaning in my dictionary is 'disgrace' and not 'tired')
湛Dam5:湿。《诗经·召南》“湛湛露斯”
(meaning in my dictionary is 'wet with dew', so this is very close)
宰 T'ai: Kill (C consonant in mandarin can be T or T' consonant in minnan)
Any arguments here ?
Re: Benzi/Original character
delete
Last edited by xng on Sun Sep 06, 2009 4:14 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Benzi/Original character
Another character where the character has a different consonant from mandarin/cantonese is 鳥.Mark Yong wrote:Andrew,
That one has floored me for ages. 林寶卿 suggests that it is 告, but I find it difficult to justify. 就 has a close-enough meaning, but the problem would be reconciling the k- vs. ch- initials.
This has a 'C'iau consonant rather than the 'N' consonant of mandarin/cantonese.
So 到 having a 'K' consonant is not impossible. The literary pronounciation is 'Tau' for 到底 with the same tone as 'Kau'. So this is the closest character.
Re: Benzi/Original character
I also find 就 (lit. ciu7) unlikely for kau3, as they are of different tones.
Re: Benzi/Original character
Does anybody have the original meaning of this character 刣 ?
I can't find the meaning in modern mandarin dictionary or even the cantonese website.
I can't find the meaning in modern mandarin dictionary or even the cantonese website.